I've been following this story for a while, and I've read the opinions of this young woman (mostly negative), and for the life of me, I can't understand what the fuss is about. Neither can she. After all, she's only putting up her virginity to the highest bidder so she can afford graduate school.
Before we set forth, let us define female virginity, at least for the sake of this blog post. Since it can be determined so easily, the physical definition dominates in most societies: once a woman's hymen is broken, she is no longer a virgin. However, as gynecologists (and ladies) are aware, a broken hymen can occur from non-sexual activity: an accident, horseback riding, or a medical problem. (The writer Florence King once described a trip to the gynecologist when she was a teenager; she was suffering from unusually painful menstrual cramps, and the doctor decided to break her hymen [not in the traditional way] in hopes of correcting the problem. So that her future husband wouldn't be offended by the lack of blood on the wedding night bedsheets, the doctor presented her with a certificate of virginity.) The converse of this is that sexual intercourse doesn't necessarily break the hymen. Although there are other common methods of sexual intercourse that do not involve the vagina, the broken hymen through sexual intercourse is still considered the symbol of lost female virginity, so for the sake of this post, we'll go with that.
"Natalie Dylan" (not her real name) has the religious right all worked up, probably because there's absolutely nothing they can do about this young woman and her auction. Everything about this auction is completely legal: the transaction would take place at the Moonlite Bunny Ranch, a legal brothel in Nevada. The auction itself is private, handled by the Bunny Ranch. Ms. Dylan announced the auction on (where else?) Howard Stern's radio show last September, and it's been garnering publicity ever since. And everyone involved benefits: Ms. Dylan makes a few million for less than an hour's worth of work, the Bunny Ranch gets a ton of publicity, and the winner gets laid.
In a country where virginity pledges are frequently made (and just as frequently broken), where teenage girls kneel before their fathers in purity balls, I find it almost refreshing that someone placed a value on female virginity. (Male virginity, of course, isn't worth a nickel.) On the other hand, one should ask the question: what's the big deal about female virginity?
There are several theories out there about the value of female virginity, from sociological to anthropological to theological. And I could write an entire book about the subject if there weren't already more than a few out there already. One could ask the owners and ex-owners of "their virtue," I suppose, but one will probably find just as many reasons as there are theories. I've had my share of girlfriends as well as two marriages and dozens of female friends, and their own reasons (and, by extension, how they valued their virginity) vary widely. Some just wanted to get their virginity out of the way; they found it little more than a nuisance and decided to lose it quietly and quickly. Others placed a certain value on it, waiting until their wedding night to lose it. Many others were somewhere in between, waiting for the "ideal boy," or offering it to a long-time boyfriend, or sleeping with an acquaintance in their dorm room. Some were cold sober, others drank or otherwise medicated themselves to fight off their unease. Some planned it weeks or months in advance, others succumbed to a whim. There are also the tragic instances of rape or other sexual abuse. Whatever the circumstances, they placed a certain value (presumbly non-monetary) on their virginity, and I'll bet none of them thought $3.8 million.
Why is Ms. Dylan doing this? Her stated reason is to pay for her graduate school studies, but given her appearance on Howard Stern's radio show, her motives do not strike me as (forgive the pun) pure. She picked her publicity well; she chose a high-profile brothel with national exposure (it had been featured on HBO's show "Cathouse") as her sponsor, she chatted with Howard Stern, shrewdly tapping into the obvious audience to promote her and her auction. She is not a poor little lady desperate to pay her bills. There are other ways of paying for graduate school. Is Natalie Dylan a fraud? After all, it's a private auction. It's quite possible. I doubt it, though.
In my opinion, when you tear away the publicity, the morals, and the sociological implacations of placing a monetary value on a maidenhead, what you have is a simple transaction. And if our society values capitalism above other institutions, this transaction should have no more sociological, moral, or publicity value than purchasing a tangerine at the grocery store. And maybe, just maybe, if more young ladies sold off their virtue to pathetic millionaires, folks would see the loss of virginity not as some holy icon on the mantle, but as a perfectly natural activity on the road to adulthood. Or at least the price might go down.